Score: 8

"Nice."

submission: (WF1)Story book promises 1.5

date: June 14, 2008

Somehow the beginning melody with the synths didn't make it for me, but the one after it, around 00:41, was something that really stood out. Fits for many different things. You could always see if some more instruments would make the song better, maybe some quiet strings to go with the starting melody too. Maybe.

Pretty good mixing, pretty good melodies, You get 8/10 and 4/5.

Score: 9

"Man, I'd like to hear this with real guitars"

submission: The Egyptian Symphony Of Death

date: June 14, 2008

I gotta give a 9/10 for that, real guitars would have fucking owned with this composition. Nice orchestral stuff between, however I think somewhere around this song are those integration problems aswell which I told you about in my other review :P

Very nice, keep it going. And get yourself a good recording opportunity with the guitars :P

Score: 9

"Very nice, I like your vocal work alot."

submission: Adapt to the Horde (vocals)

date: June 14, 2008

9/10 and fived.

The mixing could be better. You should have lifted up the volume since it's a bit too silent in my opinion.

Very nice melodies, and I really like your growling and (your dad's it seems :P) clean stuff there.

Keep it up, man.

Score: 8

"Fitting for an older video game boss music"

submission: The Black Count's War

date: June 14, 2008

The melody is more than fitting to it, but I must say, the drums just plain suck :P

I like the rest of the stuff, though it (maybe) could have more differing in the progression. But nice going anyway.

You'll get 8/10, 4/5, 3.63 / 5.00 (+ 0.069).

Score: 9

"More integration needed, IMO"

submission: Serenade Le Devil

date: June 14, 2008

The melodies are very nice, and fit together, but what bothers me when listening to this is the fact that the changes from orchestral parts to metal parts pretty often went suddenly and with more integration I mean having, for example, the guitars start out a bit before the measure when the part has changed. To give the song a more lively feel.

The melodies remind me of Heroes tunes, and I very much like those, so it's a big bonus for you :P

Very nice, keep it up.

Score: 9

"I feel bad for giving 9/10, but..."

submission: Necessary Suffering

date: June 14, 2008

Even the song itself is a fucking kickass song, I need to take into consideration the fact that the vocals could have been mixed better into the song. Don't get me wrong, it's awesome as it is already, but I'm a picky bastard :P

Anyway, you get a five outta this.

Score: 10

"Damn"

submission: Ecneibma

date: June 14, 2008

Sounds very nice, eerie feel with relaxing drums. I'm thinking whether the drums would have sounded better (notice thinking, I'm not actually giving an advice here :P) with less reverb, now they're very roomy, but it's down to what kind of a feeling you want to give it, of course. I like this one alot anyways.

And the piano annoying? It added a very nice touch for it. Your sister clearly doesn't know what she's talking about :P

Score: 10

"Lovely."

submission: Warehouse of Neglect (Metal)

date: June 7, 2008

I like how the brutally basement-like approach to the sound fits this like a glove. And nice riffs all along.

Score: 9

"Very good"

submission: _-={Victorious Day}=-_

date: May 19, 2008

I like the melody much, but I was left hoping for more rhythmic approach. Especially after the "intro", it needs more apparent bass drummings than there is at the moment IMO. I believe it would have been even more epic with bigger and louder bass drums and some rototom action.

Still, very good. Deserves a 9 IMO.

Score: 10

"Very nice."

submission: -Orr- Four Brave Champions

date: May 18, 2008

This one's very epic. I like the way you handle the melody and the rhythm. Deserves the appreciation it gets.

I wanna ask you, what did you use for your choir? Sang them by yourself or used a software?